Reset Password

Advanced Search
Guests

Kelleys Island, Ohio Rentals

no thumb
Downtown Flat
locationMax. # Guests: 6
locationBedrooms: 2  /  locationBathrooms: 2
no thumb
KI Cape Cod
locationMax. # Guests: 10
locationBedrooms: 4  /  locationBathrooms: 2
no thumb
Hook, Wine and Sinker – Secluded 4 Bedroom Kelleys Island Re
locationMax. # Guests: 12
locationBedrooms: 4  /  locationBathrooms: 2.5
no thumb
Bertsch’s On The Rock
locationMax. # Guests: 10
locationBedrooms: 5  /  locationBathrooms: 2
no thumb
Goldeneye Hideaway
locationMax. # Guests: 6
locationBedrooms: 3  /  locationBathrooms: 1
no thumb
Fun At Kelleys
locationMax. # Guests: 6
locationBedrooms: 2  /  locationBathrooms: 2
no thumb
Lookout Point Cottage
locationMax. # Guests: 8
locationBedrooms: 3  /  locationBathrooms: 2
no thumb
Island Time – Quarry Condo 8B
locationMax. # Guests: 6
locationBedrooms: 2  /  locationBathrooms: 2
no thumb
Uncle Tony’s – Quarry Condo 1C
locationMax. # Guests: 4
locationBedrooms: 2  /  locationBathrooms: 2
no thumb
The Upper Deck at The Library – Downtown Rental
locationMax. # Guests: 8
locationBedrooms: 3  /  locationBathrooms: 2
no thumb
A Break at The Lake
locationMax. # Guests: 8
locationBedrooms: 3  /  locationBathrooms: 3
no thumb
Destination Downtown – Condo 1e – 2 bedroom 2 bath Kelleys I
locationMax. # Guests: 6
locationBedrooms: 2  /  locationBathrooms: 2
no thumb
Quarry’s Edge – Condo 5B
locationMax. # Guests: 6
locationBedrooms: 2  /  locationBathrooms: 2
no thumb
The Getaway
locationMax. # Guests: 6
locationBedrooms: 3  /  locationBathrooms: 2
no thumb
Downtown – Division Street Retreat
locationMax. # Guests: 8
locationBedrooms: 3  /  locationBathrooms: 2
no thumb
Wild Pear Cottage
locationMax. # Guests: 8
locationBedrooms: 3  /  locationBathrooms: 3
no thumb
The Shores of Long Point
locationMax. # Guests: 8
locationBedrooms: 4  /  locationBathrooms: 4
no thumb
Quarry Lake Cabin
locationMax. # Guests: 8
locationBedrooms: 3  /  locationBathrooms: 2
no thumb
On The Rocks – Kelleys Island Lakefront Cottage
locationMax. # Guests: 6
locationBedrooms: 3  /  locationBathrooms: 2
no thumb
Oars, Shores and Anchors
locationMax. # Guests: 6
locationBedrooms: 3  /  locationBathrooms: 2
no thumb
Great Escape West
locationMax. # Guests: 2
locationBedrooms: 1  /  locationBathrooms: 1
no thumb
Western Breeze Lakefront Cottage
locationMax. # Guests: 10
locationBedrooms: 4  /  locationBathrooms: 2
no thumb
Lakeview Lower
locationMax. # Guests: 2
locationBedrooms: 1  /  locationBathrooms: 1
no thumb
BKs Beach House
locationMax. # Guests: 10
locationBedrooms: 3  /  locationBathrooms: 2
no thumb
Point of View
locationMax. # Guests: 6
locationBedrooms: 3  /  locationBathrooms: 2
no thumb
The Stone House – Downtown 5 Bedroom
locationMax. # Guests: 14
locationBedrooms: 5  /  locationBathrooms: 4
no thumb
Andy’s Place
locationMax. # Guests: 4
locationBedrooms: 2  /  locationBathrooms: 2
no thumb
Lakeview Upper
locationMax. # Guests: 3
locationBedrooms: 1  /  locationBathrooms: 1
no thumb
Cozy Corner – Kelleys Island Rental
locationMax. # Guests: 10
locationBedrooms: 4  /  locationBathrooms: 3
no thumb
Living on The Edge
locationMax. # Guests: 9
locationBedrooms: 3  /  locationBathrooms: 2
no thumb
WildFlower
locationMax. # Guests: 8
locationBedrooms: 3  /  locationBathrooms: 1
no thumb
KI Hideaway
locationMax. # Guests: 12
locationBedrooms: 4  /  locationBathrooms: 3
no thumb
PJ’s Beach House
locationMax. # Guests: 6
locationBedrooms: 3  /  locationBathrooms: 1.5
no thumb
KI Sunset Cottage
locationMax. # Guests: 8
locationBedrooms: 4  /  locationBathrooms: 2
no thumb
The Farm House
locationMax. # Guests: 10
locationBedrooms: 5  /  locationBathrooms: 2
no thumb
MILLION DOLLAR LAKE VIEW! Beautifully Updated Home On The...
locationMax. # Guests: 8
locationBedrooms: 4  /  locationBathrooms: 2
no thumb
Lucky Stone Cottage
locationMax. # Guests: 8
locationBedrooms: 2  /  locationBathrooms: 1
no thumb
Great Escape East
locationMax. # Guests: 2
locationBedrooms: 1  /  locationBathrooms: 1
no thumb
Blue Heron Hideaway
locationMax. # Guests: 10
locationBedrooms: 4  /  locationBathrooms: 4
no thumb
Above The Rest – Condo 5F
locationMax. # Guests: 8
locationBedrooms: 2  /  locationBathrooms: 2
no thumb
Decked Out
locationMax. # Guests: 12
locationBedrooms: 4  /  locationBathrooms: 4
no thumb
Patty’s on the Lake
locationMax. # Guests: 2
locationBedrooms: 1  /  locationBathrooms: 1
no thumb
The Cottage on Sunset
locationMax. # Guests: 6
locationBedrooms: 2  /  locationBathrooms: 1
no thumb
Hattie’s Hideaway
locationMax. # Guests: 12
locationBedrooms: 4  /  locationBathrooms: 3.5
no thumb
Whitetail Retreat
locationMax. # Guests: 7
locationBedrooms: 3  /  locationBathrooms: 2

Kelleys Island, Ohio Rentals - Home, Cottages, Condos and Rooms

  • About Stay On KI

    StayOnKI.com is the headquarters for planning your stay on Kelleys Island, Ohio. This includes homes, cottages, condominiums and other types of vacation rentals for rent on Kelleys Island.

    Kelleys Island is located in the western basin of Lake Erie about four miles north of Marblehead and twelve miles from Sandusky on the Ohio mainland. The entire island measures more than four square miles and is the largest American island in Lake Erie. A short drive from major cities makes Kelleys seem right next door, yet the Canadian Border lies only a few miles north of the island.

  • Get News About Last Minute Openings!

Copyright 2018-2020 | Stay On KI. All Rights Reserved.